The 2025 September Domain Sales Report: What Really Happened & What You Should Do

If you follow the domain aftermarket, September 2025 delivered some big headlines — but the real story is in the details. A handful of six-figure (and higher) domain name sales caught media attention, especially in new gTLDs, while the underlying market continued to show healthy liquidity and disciplined buyer behavior. In this article we’ll unpack:

• The top sales of September
• Key metrics and trends from the month
• What drove the activity
• What sellers should know — and what buyers should do
• How to position yourself going into Q4

Whether you’re a domain investor, a brand buyer, or just tracking aftermarket trends, you’ll get strategic take-aways that apply now.

---

1. Top Domain Sales of September 2025

Here are some of the most notable publicly-reported deals from the month:

Domain	Extension	Approx. Price	Why it matters
Super.xyz	.xyz	~$287,607	One of the highest new gTLD sales of the year; validates premium single-word new-gTLDs.
Intelligence.xyz	.xyz	~$150,000	Reinforces the “premium new gTLD single word” theme.
AusGov.com	.com	~$130,000	Shows the continuing strong demand for short/brandable .coms.
Queen.io	.io	~$108,500	Non-.com but premium brandable; underscores niche buyer interest in tech-facing extensions.
Other mid to high five-figure .coms	.com	$25k-$115k+	The daily “bread & butter” for aftermarket activity: short generics, keyword heavy names.

These deals matter not just for their dollar amounts — they show which names are resonating, which extensions are being paid up for, and where liquidity is most robust.

---

2. September 2025 Metrics & Market Snapshot

While full monthly totals are always somewhat incomplete (not all sales get reported), here are a few useful data-points:

• On September 7, one of the top sales was Astana.com at ~$23,000. Total reported for the day was ~$379,332, with an average ~US$807 per domain. dn.com
• On September 15, a huge outlier: Divinity.com sold for ~$795,000. Total for the day was ~$1,533,020 with average ~$2,828. dn.com
• On September 26, the top sale: AusGov.com ~$130,000. Total daily reported ~US$533,687, average ~$1,005.06. dn.com
• On September 27, top sale: MerchantSolutions.com ~$25,000. Total for the day ~$333,918, average ~$743.69. dn.com

From these “snapshots,” we can infer:

• The market continues to feature both small-ticket and large-ticket deals.
• Some large outliers pull up the average significantly (example: the Divinity.com day).
• Short, generic, brand-friendly names remain the liquidity drivers.
• Buyer trust via escrow/brokered platforms plays a key role.

In terms of extension trends: while many extensions trade, the .com remains dominant, but new gTLDs (like .xyz, .io) are increasingly making their mark when the name is exceptional.

---

3. Key Themes & Drivers from September

Here are the major forces I observed:

3.1 The “new gTLD moment”

September’s largest deals included new gTLD extensions (.xyz and .io). That suggests buyer willingness to pay premium prices outside .com — but only for very strong names (single word, clear brandable meaning). The Super.xyz and Intelligence.xyz deals were standout examples.

3.2 Established broker/marketplace infrastructure matter

Large transactions worked through recognized brokers/marketplaces (Atom, Afternic, Sedo, etc). That institutionalization gives buyers and sellers confidence, reduces friction, and supports higher price points.

3.3 Category keywords & branding over pure speculating

Many of the names that sold were meaningful words (Queen.io, Intelligence.xyz) or tied to geos/business (AusGov.com). Buyers appear to evaluate not just the name but fit for brand/product — not blind speculation.

3.4 Concentration of value in outliers

As with many aftermarket markets, a small number of big deals accounted for a disproportionate share of dollar volume. Many names still trade modestly; the “six-figure sale” remains rare.

3.5 Liquidity still present

Despite macro uncertainties, the fact we are seeing daily six-figure aggregate figures (e.g., >$500K on 26 Sept) shows the aftermarket remains active. Buyers are still allocating budget.

---

4. What Sellers Should Do (Actionable)

If you hold domain assets and are thinking of selling, here’s what the September 2025 activity suggests you should do:

• Focus on high-quality names: Short, single-word or strong two-word, brandable names with clear meaning command the best prices.
• Don’t limit yourself to .com only — although .com carries the most weight, new gTLDs can perform well if the name is strong.
• Use a broker/marketplace for high value deals: They provide reach, vetting, escrow support — which buyers are willing to pay for.
• Price smartly using comparables: Use historical data (NameBio, DNJournal) to benchmark your name.
• Be ready to pitch the value: A one-page summary of your name, use-case, traffic/SEO value (if any), and asking price can help.
• Use escrow + clear contract: For large deals, having escrow and a structured transfer timeline reduces risk and can allow you to command better terms.

---

5. What Buyers Should Do (Actionable)

If you’re buying domains (for your brand, product or investment), here are the smart steps:

• Have a clear use-case: The best deals are being done by buyers who intend to build/operate, not just wait for resale.
• Be early on meaningful extensions: If you believe in a new gTLD (for example for a tech/product brand), a short strong name in .io/.xyz/.app may be “cheaper” than the equivalent .com.
• Use escrow/broker to execute: Large deals typically go through trusted venues; avoid risky direct transfers.
• Be prepared to negotiate seriously: For premium names you may need to pay up. Have a budget, and be ready for structured payment or contingency terms.
• Mind brand & SEO factors: Extension still impacts perception; for global consumer-facing brands .com remains safest. But if your target audience is niche/developer/tech, a new gTLD may fit better.

---

6. The SEO & Branding Implication: .com or Something Else?

Here’s how to think about extension choice:

• SEO-wise: From a purely search-engine ranking perspective, modern search engines treat gTLDs neutrally — content and links matter much more than the extension. So a great .io or .xyz can compete.
• Brand/trust-wise: .com still carries broad global recognition and trust. If your domain is consumer-facing and you’ll rely on general population recognition, .com remains strong.
• Risk/availability trade-off: Many premium .coms are gone or extremely expensive. If you find a short, strong brandable name in a newer extension and it fits your product/audience, it may offer better value — and September’s activity shows buyers are paying for those.
• Use-case centric decision: If your brand is tech, product-focused, crypto/AI, developer-oriented, a .io/.app/.xyz may align with your audience — if you’re building a mass-market consumer brand, long-term .com may still be worth the premium.

---

7. Checklist for Selling (Step-by-Step)

Here’s a practical checklist you can follow, inspired by what many sellers did in September:

1. Run comparables: Use NameBio and DNJournal to identify recent sales for similar length/keyword/extension names.
2. Gather domain age, WHOIS history, traffic/lead metrics (if any) — buyers pay for provenance.
3. Prepare a one-page pitch: Domain name, extension, key use-case(s), asking price/range, transfer/escrow plan.
4. List on a reputable marketplace or approach a broker.
5. Engage private outreach: Identify likely end-users (brands, businesses) and send them your pitch.
6. Negotiate terms: Be ready for escrow, structured payment, seller hold-back if required.
7. Execute transfer under escrow: Use trusted escrow service, get contract signed, ensure all parties protected.
8. After sale: Update public sales data (optional) — helps build visibility for you as a seller.

---

8. Risks & Things to Keep in Mind

• Headline sales can skew perception. Just because a few $100K+ deals occur doesn’t mean every name will sell for tens of thousands. Most domains will trade much lower.
• Reporting is incomplete. Many sales are private and don’t show up in NameBio or public datasets, so the publicly-reported market is only part of the picture.
• Market cycles matter. Even with strong months like September, macro environment, credit/finance, technology trends all influence buyer budgets and appetite.
• Extension risks. While new gTLDs are performing for some premium names, many are still less liquid than .com — careful evaluation is essential.

---

9. Final Thoughts & Takeaway

September 2025 reinforced a few truths: short, brandable names with meaning command premium prices; new gTLDs are increasingly part of the mix; and brokers/marketplaces with escrow infrastructure remain vital for high-value deals. If you’re a seller, use this moment to position your best assets. If you’re a buyer, move with purpose and clarity. But always stay realistic: the big wins are the exception, not the rule.